Dennis's Auto Blog Subscribe To This Blog Embed with Spring Widgets
Wednesday April 23, 2008 at 5:49 pm
The Conspiracy Theory And MPG


My wife and I stayed at a B and B recently. Conversation around the breakfast table with other guests the next morning covered all sorts of topics until one of the guys started talking about cars and fuel mileage. A fellow auto enthusiast! Now they're talking my language!

Several of the older guests complained how this small car or that small car back in the 1970's got fifty miles-per-gallon and now even the highest mileage machines are only achieving thirty-eight MPG or so. Technology hasn't advanced at all when to comes to fuel mileage they exclaimed.

I reminded them that most cars now are much larger because consumers want the comfort. Cars are also heavier due to added safety features like front and side airbags, anti-lock brake systems and more. And luxury features like premium sound systems and road noise deadening material all add weight to modern cars. On top of that, consumers want more performance so engines are larger with more horsepower, even in most compact cars. Throw in the mileage reducing factor of ten-percent ethanol fuel and it all adds up.

One of the guests then declared, "Well the car makers could make very high mileage cars but they are conspiring with big oil companies to keep the mileage down and oil profits up." He went on to mention how cars in research competitions can achieve a hundred miles per gallon or more.

Remember, high mileage research vehicles are not only tiny in most cases, the technology and materials used to reach those lofty mileage goals are usually very expensive. It reminds me of the time I was able to drive one of Honda's fuel cell powered cars during the New York International Auto Show a few years ago. As I zipped in and out of mid-town Manhattan traffic in the zero-emissions machine, I asked the Honda engineer riding along how much the car was worth. " Oh about a million-point-seven I suppose," he said. That made me slow down a bit I can tell you.

The thing we need to remember is the manufacturing cost of a car is a very important factor in the fuel mileage it can achieve. I do not buy into any "conspiracy theory" at all. The market place dictates what cars manufacturers mass produce and the mileage they achieve. If car companies introduce a car and the public does not buy it, it fails. Pure and simple.

The first fully electric car with a realistic range between battery charges will soon be available. The "Tesla" will sell for about $100,000 for a two-seater. That's not exactly the next model "T". With gasoline now at three-and-a-half dollars a gallon, the government should not mandate minimum fuel mileage to car makers. You will take care of that by the cars you choose to buy and drive.

Your Name
(appears on your post)
For security reasons, please type in the above letters



Please leave your comments below:

Comments on The Conspiracy Theory And MPG
Dennis Buterbaugh, abc27 News
Here is just a sample of what I'm talking about:

1968 Ford Mustang GT 2659 lbs.

2008 Ford Mustang GT 3500 lbs.

1970 Dodge Challenger 3600 lbs.

2008 Dodge Challenger 4200 lbs.

1996 BMW 335i 3234 lbs.

2008 BMW 3351 3600 lbs.

Much of the added weight comes from better crash test protection now compared to years ago.

john from middletown
I believe the car manufacturers could build more efficient cars if they wanted to but we the comsumer won't let them. Several years ago everybody wanted more power so the car companies granted our wish and gave us more power but not overnight(it takes years) now we want better fuel economy but it's gonna take time because the car companies are still building more powerful engines. They have to totally changing the goals of the engineers and that takes time. This is only my opinion for what its worth.

Harry
Williams Roberts

Car companies did much in the way of making cars lighter, however, the only changes to the car in the 70's era was the catalytic converter that was mandated by the U.S. government. The catalytic converter caused a loss in horsepower.

The gas crisis in the early to mid 70's caused the era to change from powerful V8 to V6's and 4-cylinders to get more MPG.

In the late 70's early 80's thing started changing with the imports you mentioned. They started to be imported with the reduced emissions ( catalytic converter) and were better MPG than big three could make at the time. The European cars have better emissions, because there country mandate it. Two I know for sure are Japan, and China. They have stricter emission standards than the U.S.

C Warner
Dennis I agree with you wholeheartedly. We are a spoiled society and a throwaway one at that. We expect our cars to have heated seats, power seats, adjustable pedals, power windows, power locks, and the list goes on. What ever happened to rolling your window down with a crank.

I have a 1967 model year car with a 302 v-8 that gets the same gas mileage as my 1994 fuel injected vehicle. Americans need to stop buying gas guzzling huge Suvs and new cars in general. If we keep paying the prices for them they will keep charging those $30,000.00 price tags for a car thats worth maybe $2000.00 by the end of your payments for trade in value.

More expensive and bigger cars are not always better. My next vehicle will have better gas mileage than the one I currently own and I will be looking for less options not more. Ask a car salesperson to show you a car with manual windows and they look at you like your crazy.

No Not crazy just practical. No window motor to go out when its pouring down raining at the bank drivethru. Just a thought.

William Roberts
Dennis, I do not agree with you that cars are much larger, heavier and more powerful than they were in the the 50's through 70's. Cars have been made lighter using aluminum and plastics. Every US manufacturer back then had huge V8 engines. Chrysler developed the ever popular Hemi back then. Open the bonnet of an old car and a new car and take a look. I think you will see a lot of the reason for reduced fuel economy, if you can even see the engine in a new car. Although the new cars are technologically much more advanced, there is a lot more going on in there. In the 70's cars were changed to reduce emissions. This was the beginning of lower fuel economy. This is also the reason that many European cars were stopped from being imported. They are still being marketed in Europe with good economy. But that is only my opinion and I am "auto mechanically declined"

Terry LEBANON
Hey Dennis read the ad to the left www.waterforgas,tv. what do you think, it sounds like a bunch of bull to me

Frances Buchanan
The government should not force auto manufacturers to produce cars with more mileage. The problem with the gasoline prices needs to be addressed. There is no reason gas and oil should be the price they are. Do something about fuel prices not the car themselves. Cars aren"t the problem.

TM & © TM & © Harrisburg Television, Inc.
Please read our Privacy Policy. By using this site, you accept our Terms of Service.
Children's Television | EEO Reports | DTV Consumer Education Reports
WHTM-TV adheres to the ICRA RATING SYSTEM

Pages throughout the WHTM website feature links to other sites, some of which are operated by companies unrelated to WHTM-TV.
WHTM-TV has no control over the content or availability of any linked site.

Legal Notices. "TM & © Harrisburg Television, Inc.", recognizes the privacy interests of visitors to this site on the Internet.

Satellite Home Viewer Act Information | WHTM EEO Reports CLICK HERE
{ts '2008-05-09 13:53:54'}